Primavera P3 Software Review: University of Cincinnati
User Review
Raymond A.Miller
Review Summary
Raymond Miller began building power plants for GE in 1978. At that time, the only computers were at GE headquarters in Schenectady, N.Y., and all data input was done via unreliable dial-up phone terminal interfaces with thermal printers. In the 1980s he began using Primavera construction project management software -- and has been using it ever since.
Over the years he has worked in a variety of industries and has also used MS Project, Harvard Project, Timeline and Open Plan, but he keeps returning to the Primavera software due to its "logical approach to building projects, detailed reporting structures and robust data analysis."
"Using Primavera I managed the construction and commissioning of a 612MW steam turbine generator project for Dayton Power and Light and completed the project three months ahead of schedule and saved DP&L over $100 million. I used (Primavera) P3 to manage multimillion dollar turbine overhauls in five to six weeks when these outages historically took eight or nine weeks. Missing a start-up date on an overhaul can incur $100,000/shift penalties."
The University of Cincinnati paid $3,000 for a licensed copy of P3e/c, and Miller currently uses the program for its simplicity of report writing, as well as its ease of use for building projects. In addition, it has a "robust hierarchical structure, cost, and resource allocation, and integrates with Timberline for ongoing process improvement."
Miller said the best feature is "the ability to rapidly lay out and develop a project schedule without a huge investment in time." This speed paid off on his most recent project as a "late start up would have cost UC approximately $5mil due to added energy and demand charges."
There isn't anything Miller would change about Primavera P3, and, as this version has been adequately serving his construction project management needs for four years, he has no plans to upgrade anytime soon. Overall, he rated the program a 9 out of 10, and concludes that: "Since I have started using Primavera and predecessor applications almost 30 years ago, I have developed projects with more detailed specifications for schedule, deliverables, and resources."
Full Review
Over 25 years of versions of this application.
Power plants, industrial facilities RRR and custom rock trenching.
University licensed copy.
$3,000.
Utility construction project management.
Extensive experience with it. Simplicity of report writing, ease of use for building projects, robust hierarchical structure, cost and resource allocation integrates with Timberline for ongoing process improvement.
Other vendor applications I have used include MS Project, Timeline, Open Plan and Harvard Project. Open Plan requires operating within a database application like Oracle, Access or SQL to access data for reporting. The other applications are usable but not as flexible as the Primavera applications.
Since I have started using Primavera and predecessor applications almost 30 years ago, I have developed projects with more detailed specifications for schedule, deliverables and resources.
Power plant construction project for the University of Cincinnati (UC). Construction project management software assured a concurrently designed plant to start up on time and on budget -- a rarity in the power industry.
Late start-up would have cost UC approximately $5 million due to added energy and demand charges.
The ability to rapidly lay out and develop a project schedule without a huge investment in time.
Yes, absolutely.
Nothing.
For many of my projects, I use standard report specifications. I don't often tailor them any more.
Anyone managing construction projects of significant scope and dollars should use Primavera P3.
One needs to be fairly computer literate.
I never had training. I learned the application through use.
No.
Very detailed and supportive when needed.
Not necessarily. My current version (Primavera P3) has been serving me well for four years.
9
Company Overview
Seattle-based Dexter + Chaney Inc. specializes in construction accounting and construction project management software. The company was founded in 1981 and provides its software to clients throughout the United States. Dexter + Chaney has developed an integrated construction management software package called Spectrum Construction Software.
9700 Lake City Way NE
Seattle, WA
Web: dexterchaney.com
Find Software Tips
Latest reviews by topic
- Field Management (2)
- Imaging (5)
- Risk Analysis (3)
- Cost Estimating (34)
- CRM (7)
- Engineering/CAD (13)
- Job Cost Accounting (44)
- On Screen Takeoff (10)
- Project Management (76)
- Scheduling and Resourcing (49)
Latest reviews by industry
- Commercial (78)
- Concrete (37)
- Design/Build Firm (39)
- Electrical Contractor (40)
- Energy (Oil/Gas) (28)
- General Contracting (74)
- Government (54)
- Healthcare (35)
- Heavy and Highway (69)
- Industrial (73)
- Insurance (20)
- Landscape (24)
- Masonry (24)
- Mechanical Contractor (24)
- Mixed Use (68)
- New Construction (37)
- Plumbing Contractor (28)
- Repair/Remodeling (41)
- Residential (78)
- School (34)
- Subcontractor (39)
- Utilities (29)
